A Persuasive Doing: The Subjective Discourse of Science

Introduction

In "A Persuasive Doing: The Subjective Discourse of Science," Maria José Coracini argues that science is not a purely objective enterprise, but rather a social activity that is shaped by subjective factors such as persuasion and rhetoric. She draws on a variety of sources, including the history of science, sociology of science, and philosophy of science, to support her claim.

The History of Science

Coracini begins by examining the history of science, arguing that it is not a linear progression of objective discoveries, but rather a complex process of trial and error, in which scientists are constantly trying to persuade each other of their theories. She cites examples such as the Copernican Revolution, in which Nicolaus Copernicus's heliocentric model of the solar system was initially rejected by many scientists because it contradicted the prevailing Ptolemaic model.

The Sociology of Science

Coracini then turns to the sociology of science, arguing that the social context of science plays a significant role in shaping the way that scientists conduct their research and communicate their findings. She discusses factors such as the power dynamics within scientific institutions, the influence of funding sources, and the role of the media in shaping public perceptions of science.

The Philosophy of Science

Finally, Coracini examines the philosophy of science, arguing that the traditional view of science as a purely objective enterprise is based on a flawed understanding of the nature of knowledge. She draws on the work of philosophers such as Thomas Kuhn and Michel Foucault to argue that science is a human activity that is inevitably shaped by subjective factors.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Coracini argues that science is not a purely objective enterprise, but rather a social activity that is shaped by subjective factors such as persuasion and rhetoric. She calls for a more nuanced understanding of science that takes into account its social and cultural context.

Why You Should Read This Book

"A Persuasive Doing: The Subjective Discourse of Science" is a must-read for anyone interested in the history, sociology, or philosophy of science. Coracini's book provides a wealth of evidence to support her claim that science is not a purely objective enterprise, but rather a social activity that is shaped by subjective factors. She writes in a clear and engaging style, making her book accessible to a wide range of readers.

If you are interested in learning more about the real nature of science, then I highly recommend reading "A Persuasive Doing: The Subjective Discourse of Science." You will not be disappointed.